Playback error - lost tuner or disconnect

I believe that hard drive was first released around 2009.
Also it’s a Western Digital Green drive, which saves power by going to sleep a lot.
The Tablo works well with many different hard drives, but those drives are the newer drives.

My drive works great:
WD 2TB Elements Portable WDBU6Y0020BBK-NESN

Here’s a post of user tested drives: