SurLaTablo.py - Python program to query and convert Tablo recordings


#710

Spasibo


#711

Took me a bit to realize I translated from Russian to English without thinking about it. :slight_smile:


#712

Yeah, weird how the mind works. That popped up in my mind when he answered my question. I haven’t spoken Russian since the two semesters of it I took in the early '80s.


#714

Removed, wrong thread


#716

Honest mistake with multiple windows open. Hit my post button in wrong thread


#717

I just found this and am testing it out. The one thing that perhaps rubs me the wrong way more than it should, is that the config file is not a hidden file. Have you considered using ‘~/.surlatablo2.conf’ instead (adding the leading dot)? Even better on Linux would be something like ‘~/.config/surlatabo2.conf’, but that requires a conditional platform check based on the OS.

In the meantime, I’m patching the local copy of the script myself.


#718

It’s configurable… and there’s those pesky Windows folks…


#719

With the firmware update to add 5.1 audio, it would appear that the Mp4 “straight-thru” option is producing zero-length files. I am attempting to “fix” it and it would appear it may have something to do with the option “aac_adtstoasc”, but am having no luck. Anyone else solve the issue?


#720

Ugh, given the hideous nature of the implementation (sorry Nuvyyo, but you know what I mean), I was hoping to not have to troubleshoot this (sigh). Life was better without this “feature”.


#721

I thought users ask for 5.1 pass thru so that the sound from tablo would be as close as possible to the sound embedded in the actual OTA transmission?


#722

But, as Nuvyyo and others (like myself) mentioned, this problem isn’t quite as easy as it sounds. As we’ve already seen, it’s an all or nothing implementation right now. If all of your devices can handle surround (even if they dumb it down), you’re ok (and btw, that’s a very small set right now).

There’s a reason why things like Plex work. Because plex understand the client capabilities and transcodes on the fly to match the end device. This is “too much” for the Tablo hardware to do… well… let’s just say it would put even greater limits on the platform as is.

I don’t really want to say anything more until I actually can take a look at these “new” things. Who knows, I might be surprised.


#723

I didn’t say that what the users thought they were asking for made any sense, was feasible, or a good solution.

Plex loves to brag about the wonders of having the plex client perform the sound transcoding. Even trying to imply that their sound codecs were superior to all others. And if you configured plex for pass thru you could be in a world of hurt.

https://support.plex.tv/articles/212072167-audio-configuration-guide-plex-media-player/

Tip!: We do not recommend
enabling passthrough as the first thing you do. Only do that if you are
very well informed about what it entails, because it’s probably not what
you want here. Plex Media Player has the capability to perfectly
decode most “HD audio” formats, and enabling passthrough creates
drawbacks that you likely want to avoid. The “Plex Media Player decode of audio vs. Passthrough” section near the bottom of the article has useful information to read before enabling passthrough.